| Label | Distance | Category |
|---|---|---|
| Artist Lake, Middle Island, NY, USA | 0.53 mi | natural, natural:water, recreation |
| Pool, Middle Island, NY, USA | 0.71 mi | natural, natural:water, recreation |
| Spring Lake, Gordon Heights, NY, USA | 1.27 mi | natural, natural:water, recreation |
| Twin Ponds, Middle Island, NY, USA | 1.28 mi | natural, natural:water, recreation |
| Pine Lake, Middle Island, NY, USA | 1.33 mi | recreation, natural, natural:water |
| Upper Lake, Yaphank, NY, USA | 2.89 mi | natural, natural:water, recreation |